Personnel

4114.1-AR

 

CERTIFICATED PROMOTION

 

A.      Purpose and Scope

To set forth regulations regarding selection from certificated personnel for administrative/promotional positions

B.     General

1.      Since the actions of both the paper and oral screening committees affect in a significant way the professional career of a respective candidate, it must be understood and accepted by each participating member that all activities of these respective committees, i.e., all discussions, recommendations, membership, candidates, interviews, etc., shall be held in strict confidence.

2.      Each member who serves on either the paper or the oral screening committee shall be professionally obligated to adhere to the "Code of Ethics of the Teaching Profession," operating within the framework of confidentiality stressed above.

C.     Forms Used and Additional References

None

D.     Procedure

1.      Posting-Application Procedure

a.      Vacancies shall be adequately publicized. A notice shall be posted at every school, clearly setting forth a description of the qualifications for the position, including the duties and salary. The district shall inform interested candidates regarding vacancies which occur during times other than the regular school year by means of the district recording device and posting in the Personnel Office.

b.      Such notices shall be posted a minimum of six working days or as far in advance as possible.

c.      Certificated personnel who desire to apply for such vacancies shall submit their applications in writing to the Assistant Superintendent, Personnel Services, within the time limit specified in the notice.

d.      When equal qualifications prevail (i.e., professional training, experience, recommendations, ability, and other such characteristics) between a Placentia-Yorba Linda Unified School District certificated employee and an outside applicant, the in-district employee shall be given preference.

e.      All vacancies excepting the position of superintendent shall be filed in the manner prescribed by the administrative procedure.

At the conclusion of the application period for an administrative/promotional position, both paper and oral screening procedures will be followed as described under numbers 3 and 4 below.

2.      Structure and Procedure of Paper Screening Committee

a.      Membership of Committee

1)      The Assistant Superintendent, Personnel Services, may contact the teacher's association president and request that two representatives be selected to participate in a paper screening committee to review the applications of specific candidates applying for a given position.

The respective association representative shall not be eligible to serve on both the paper and the oral screening committees pertinent to a given position.

2)      Whenever appropriate, a member of the community will be selected by the Assistant Superintendent, Personnel Services, to participate in the paper screening.

3)      Two members of Management selected by the Assistant Superintendent, Personnel Services

4)      Assistant Superintendent, Personnel Services

b.      Procedure

1)      The paper screening committee shall select candidates who, by majority consensus of the committee, represent the best qualified applicants.

2)      The criteria considered in reaching this committee consensus are:

a)      The individual committee member's evaluation of the professional recommendations contained in the Placement File.

b)      A review of the candidate's credentials, degrees, experience and a comparison made with the stated requirements.

c)      An initial 1, 2, 3 ranking and grouping of all applicants done by each individual, then compared within the committee to see if a consensus has been achieved with respect to each candidate.

 

1

-

above average-surpasses minimum requirements

 

2

-

average-meets minimum requirements

 

3

-

low-does not meet minimum requirements

d)      A refinement of Step b(1) to reduce to the best candidates.

e)      If group 1 needs more candidates, group 2 shall be reviewed and those deemed best qualified move into group 1, again to build toward a field of strong candidates.

3)      Personal calls will be made by the Assistant Superintendent, Personnel Services, to the supervising administrator of the applicants to check on specific details, e.g., leadership qualities, curriculum background, reaction to pressure, verification of service, etc. Any information that has bearing shall be presented to the screening committee.

3.      Structure and Procedure of Oral Screening

a.      Membership of Committee

1)      The Assistant Superintendent, Personnel Services, may contact the teacher's association president and request that two representatives be selected to participate in an oral screening committee to interview specific candidates applying for a given position.

The respective association representative shall not be eligible to serve on both the paper and the oral screening committees pertinent to a given position.

2)      Whenever appropriate, a member of the community will be selected by the Assistant Superintendent, Personnel Services, to participate in the oral screening.

3)      Two members of Management selected by the Assistant Superintendent, Personnel Services.

4)      Assistant Superintendent, Educational Services, or designee.

5)      Assistant Superintendent, Personnel Services

6)      The superintendent may participate at his discretion.

b.      Procedure

1)      The oral screening committee will be convened and provided information by the Assistant Superintendent, Personnel Services, relative to the interviewee's professional qualifications and background.

2)      During the interview session, the representatives on the committee should ask questions which will give evidence of the qualifications of the respective candidate.

3)      Each committee member at the conclusion of all interviews will be asked to rank his choice of the screened candidates. An opportunity will be extended to each member to cite the strengths and/or weaknesses of the candidates as support for his indicated ranking.

4)      The committee members will be asked to discard or indicate their lowest ranking candidates, thereby leaving only the top two or three choices.

5)      Generally a consensus will have been reached at this point as to the top two or three candidates. If consensus is not reached, the matter will be reported to the superintendent for appropriate action.

6)      After consensus, a thorough review of the strengths and weaknesses of those top candidates will take place and finally the committee, through a process of ranking, will arrive at a consensus as to the top persons.

7)      The superintendent, who is in essence an ex-officio member of the committee, has an opportunity to delve into the reason or the rationale for the recommendation which the committee presents. It should be pointed out that in every interview the superintendent has the right, and generally exercises it, to pose some questions to each interviewee.

8)      The recommendation coming from the oral screening committee, although only advisory, shall be presented in writing to the superintendent with one copy retained by the Assistant Superintendent, Personnel Services. It is pointed out to that committee that the superintendent has the right to accept, reject, or subsequently select another person from among the candidates or request readvertisement.

9)      The superintendent shall present his recommendation in writing to the Board of Education.

10)  The Board of Education has the prerogative of rejecting the superintendent's recommendation.

11)  All applicants shall be notified as to the status of their candidacy for the respective position. Applicants who do not proceed to the oral screening committee will be notified as to the status of their candidacy. Applicants who are finalists in the oral interview sessions will be notified after appropriate action by the Board of Education.

E.     Reports Required

1.      Recommendations of Oral Screening Committee to the superintendent

2.      Recommendations of superintendent to Board of Education

3.      Notification to candidates of their status

F.      Record Retention

Personnel Services

G.     Responsible Administrative Unit

Personnel Services

H.     Approved by:

 

 

Nicholas A. Siokos

4/27/81

Keith T. Larick

4/27/81

Responsible Division Head

Date

Superintendent

Date